TimeLeaf vs Calamari: Which Leave Tool is Right for Your Team?
An honest comparison of TimeLeaf and Calamari, covering pricing, features, and which tool fits different team sizes and needs.
If you're evaluating leave management software, Calamari is probably on your shortlist. It's a solid tool with a modular approach. But depending on your team size and needs, it may not be the most cost-effective option.
Here's an honest comparison.
Pricing model
Calamari charges per module, per employee:
- Time Off: $2.50/employee/month
- Core HR: $2.50/employee/month
- Time & Attendance: $3.00/employee/month
- Performance Review: $3.00/employee/month
- SAML add-on: $1.00/employee/month
To run the full platform (leave, HR, time & attendance, performance, and SSO), a 25-person team pays $300/month ($12/employee across all five modules).
TimeLeaf bundles everything into one plan. Every plan includes 10 employees, then a flat per-person rate above that, with no separate module fees:
- Starter: $50/month (10 employees included, +$5/extra)
- Professional: $90/month (10 employees included, +$9/extra)
- Business: $120/month (10 employees included, +$12/extra)
That same 25-person team pays $225/month on TimeLeaf Professional ($90 base + 15 × $9). That's 25% less than Calamari's full stack, and that single price already bundles shift scheduling, contracts, e-signatures, and directory sync that Calamari doesn't sell at any price. Pay annually and save another 10%.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Calamari | TimeLeaf |
|---|---|---|
| Leave requests & approvals | Yes (Time Off module) | Yes (all plans) |
| Leave balance tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Time tracking / clock-in | Yes (separate module, +$3/emp) | Yes (Professional+) |
| Shift scheduling | No | Yes (Professional+) |
| Overtime management | Limited | Yes, with time banking |
| Contracts & e-signatures | No | Yes (Professional+) |
| Calendar sync (Google/Outlook) | Yes | Yes (Professional+) |
| Slack & Teams integration | Yes | Yes (Professional+) |
| Directory sync (AD/Google) | No | Yes (Professional+) |
| Custom approval workflows | Limited | Yes (Business+) |
| SSO / SAML | Add-on ($1/emp) | Included (Professional+) |
| Blackout periods | No | Yes (all plans) |
| API access | Yes (rate limited) | Yes (Professional+) |
| Performance reviews | Yes (separate module, +$3/emp) | No |
Where Calamari wins
- 14-day free trial without credit card. TimeLeaf requires a credit card for its 7-day trial.
- Modular flexibility. If you only need leave tracking and nothing else, Calamari's Time Off module at $2.50/employee is affordable.
- Performance reviews. Calamari has a dedicated performance-review module; TimeLeaf doesn't offer one.
- Longer track record. Calamari has been around longer and has more reviews on G2.
Where TimeLeaf wins
- Everything in one plan. Leave, time tracking, shifts, contracts, overtime and time-banking, SSO, and directory sync are all included, with no stacking five separate per-employee modules or doing line-item math. Matched against Calamari's full module stack, TimeLeaf runs about 25% cheaper while adding capabilities Calamari doesn't sell at all.
- Shift scheduling. Calamari doesn't offer this, so you'd need a third tool.
- Contracts and e-signatures. Built in, not available in Calamari at all.
- Overtime management and time banking. More robust than Calamari's basic tracking.
- Directory sync. Auto-import employees from Azure AD or Google Workspace.
- Blackout periods. Block leave during peak seasons, which is not available in Calamari.
Cost comparison at different team sizes
| Team Size | Calamari (full stack, $12/emp) | TimeLeaf Professional | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 employees | $120/mo | $90/mo | 25% |
| 25 employees | $300/mo | $225/mo | 25% |
| 50 employees | $600/mo | $450/mo | 25% |
That's TimeLeaf's complete bundle against Calamari's complete bundle. TimeLeaf doesn't include a standalone performance-review module. Instead the same plan adds shift scheduling, contracts and e-signatures, and directory sync that Calamari can't match. Annual billing takes another 10% off the TimeLeaf column.
Bottom line
If you only need basic leave tracking for a small team, Calamari's Time Off module is a fine choice at $2.50/employee.
If you need leave + time tracking + shifts + contracts + integrations, TimeLeaf gives you all of that in one bundled plan for about 25% less than Calamari's full module stack, plus shift scheduling, contracts, and directory sync Calamari doesn't offer at all, on a single predictable bill instead of per-module, per-employee math.
Ready to simplify leave management?
Start your 7-day free trial. Set up your team in under 30 minutes.
Start Free Trial